Even the closest business partnership needs a buy/sell agreement in place. Use this expert guide to protect everything you and your partners have built.
Sam and Dave were best mates who started a car dealership. Yet, when one of them died, their lack of a formal agreement led to a painful dispute and eventual financial ruin.
If you’re a small or medium business owner and in a partnership, you may not have thought about the implications of a partner’s death or disability. After all, it’s not the happiest of subjects. Yet a little bit of forethought on how your business could keep going if this was to happen could save a lot of heartache.
A buy/sell agreement is worth the awkward conversation. A critical agreement that sets out how ownership is transferred to other business partners should tragedy strike, it ensures that beneficiaries of the deceased person’s will – usually their family – will be paid for their share of the business, saving them additional trauma at a very difficult time.
Surprisingly, many businesses do not have one, which can lead to all sorts of unforeseen problems. Let’s look at Dave and Sam as an example.
Case study: Best mates in business
Dave and Sam were great friends. That’s why, when they started a car dealership together, they thought there was no point in having any kind of formal agreement. Nothing could go wrong, right?
When Dave passed away, Sam decided to honour a verbal agreement they’d had to pay Dave’s wife a salary, even though she wasn’t working in the business. He did this for five years until Dave’s wife died too.
At this point, Dave’s half of the business went to his three children. They had no interest in being in the business, so Sam said he’d buy them out at a price he’d verbally agreed with Dave – $1.5 million. However, since this agreement had been made over five years earlier, Dave’s children got their share of the business independently valued at $2.5 million. Sam said he could not afford to pay that without mortgaging all his assets.
The children appointed an independent director, who refused to pay Sam’s salary, saying it was too high. The independent director also raised the possibility of reporting him to the ATO for paying Dave’s wife for five years and claiming it as a tax deduction when she didn’t actually work in the business. In the end, Sam paid Dave’s children $2.2 million for their share of the business, plus all the legal fees.
How would having a buy-sell agreement have helped?
There are three main ways a buy/sell agreement would have helped in this situation:
- Simpler succession
- Insurance and funding
Let’s look at these in more detail.
First, a valuation. Putting a dollar figure on a business is not straightforward. Fixed assets, like the land the car dealership is on, are a lot easier to assign a value to than intangible assets like goodwill and future earnings. In the case of Sam and Dave, the ambiguous and outdated $1.5 million valuation was a key source of dispute.
“Often, the worth of a business depends on who is asking,” says Jeff Baldwin, Head of Advice at MLC Advice. “That’s why I advise people not to put a fixed price on a business, but instead a methodology.”
This methodology could include things like valuing a business as a multiple of revenue. That means the more money the business makes, the more it is worth. Within this methodology can also come considerations like whether it’s a 50/50 partnership, or whether one owner has put more cash or effort into growing the business. It’s likely that had Dave’s children seen there was a fair methodology for the valuation, they would not have felt the need to mount a challenge.
Next, a buy-sell agreement would have made the succession simpler and cleaner by ensuring Dave’s children never became involved in the business. Instead, following Dave’s death Sam would have become sole owner of the business right away and Dave’s family would have been paid a fair amount in return. In particular, this approach would have avoided the complicated arrangement of paying Dave’s wife that could have got Sam into trouble with the ATO, Baldwin says.
Thirdly, proper insurance would have given Sam the necessary funding. This type of insurance is called ownership protection. It functions similarly to life insurance; if one business partner dies, the other gets paid out, Baldwin explains. Had the car dealership owners had this, then Sam wouldn’t have had to worry about mortgaging his assets to buy out Dave’s kids.
Three tips for a solid buy/sell agreement
1. Start early and review often
A buy/sell agreement should be put in place at the beginning or in the early stages of the business partnership, and regularly updated.
“I would say review once a year,” Baldwin says. “Although if you have a solid methodology for valuation, it doesn’t have to be a full review. At least look at whether your insurance is still adequate, and if there’s been any changes like the establishment of a family trust.”
2. Get good advice
While a lawyer will ultimately put the document together, the complexity of the situation means it’s often best to get all your advisers across the agreement, Baldwin says.
For example, a solicitor can draft the document. A financial adviser can work with the solicitor on getting the best insurance in place and also look at the bigger picture of the client’s finances and retirement plans. And an accountant will be able to take care of tax and trust structures.
3. Decide how much insurance you need
Insurance doesn’t have to cover the entire value of the business (the higher the payout, the higher the premium).
Instead, Baldwin says, think about how much payout you need. For example, if you received a payout of two-thirds of the value of the business, would you be able to manage the rest with a bank loan?
Once you have followed these steps and have a solid buy/sell agreement in place, you will have peace of mind, knowing that the business, your partners and your loved ones will be taken care of should the worst ever happen.
Important information and disclaimer
This communication has been prepared by Bridges Financial Services Pty Ltd ABN 60 003 474 977 AFSL 240837 (‘Bridges’) trading as MLC Advice, a member of the IOOF Holdings Limited ABN 49 100 103 722 ('IOOF') group of companies (‘IOOF Group’), registered office Level 3, 30 Hickson Road, Millers Point NSW 2000, for use and distribution by representatives of MLC Advice. MLC Advice financial advisers are representatives of Bridges.
Any advice in this communication is of a general nature only and has not been tailored to your personal circumstances. Accordingly, reliance should not be placed on the information contained in this communication as the basis for making any financial investment, insurance or other decision. Please seek personal advice prior to acting on this information.
If any financial products are referred to in this communication, you should consider the relevant Product Disclosure Statement or other disclosure material before making an investment decision in relation to that financial product. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. The value of an investment may rise or fall with the changes in the market.
Information in this communication is accurate as at the date of issue. In some cases, information has been provided to us by third parties. While it is believed the information is accurate and reliable, the accuracy of that information is not guaranteed in any way. Any opinions expressed constitute our views at the time of issue and are subject to change. While care has been taken in the preparation of this communication, subject to any terms implied by law and which cannot be excluded, no liability is accepted by Bridges, IOOF or any member of the IOOF Group, their agents or employees for any loss arising from reliance on this communication.
Any tax information provided in this communication is intended as a guide only and is based on our general understanding of taxation laws. It is not intended to be a substitute for specialised taxation advice or an assessment of your liabilities, obligations or claim entitlements that arise, or could arise, under taxation law, and we recommend you consult with a registered tax agent.
Please note that any advice you receive is provided by Bridges, not IOOF or any other member of the IOOF Group. An investment with Bridges, or any other member of the IOOF Group is subject to investment risk including possible delays in repayment and loss of income and capital invested. The repayment of capital, the payment of income and any particular rate of return are not guaranteed by Bridges or any member of the IOOF Group, or any other company, unless specifically stated in a current PDS. Neither Bridges, IOOF nor any member of the IOOF Group in any way stand behind the capital value and/or performance of any investment you may make as a result of the advice you receive.